Few papers are accepted without changes. Understanding the process makes revisions less stressful, and a well-built response often decides the outcome.
How peer review works
After an editorial check, the editor sends the paper to independent experts. They comment and recommend a decision, and the editor makes the final call.
- Desk review: the editor checks scope and basic quality, and may reject at this point
- Review: usually two or more experts read the paper
- Decision: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject
- Revision: you respond, and the paper may go back to the reviewers
Types of review
Journals differ in who knows whom. Check the policy before you prepare your files, because blinded review needs an anonymised manuscript.
- Single-blind: reviewers know the authors, authors do not know the reviewers
- Double-blind: neither side knows the other
- Open: identities, and sometimes the reports, are published
Reading reviewer comments
Wait a day before replying, because first reactions to criticism are rarely the best. Sort comments into those you will act on, those you will partly act on, and those you will respectfully disagree with.
- Treat each comment as something to answer, not to defend against
- Look for the real concern behind a badly worded comment
- If two reviewers disagree, explain how you resolved it
- Ask the editor if a comment is unclear or contradicts another
Writing the response letter
- Thank the editor and reviewers briefly
- Reply point by point, quoting each comment
- Say exactly what changed and where, with page or line numbers
- Where you disagree, give evidence and stay polite
- Provide a marked-up copy and a clean copy if the journal asks for both
Key takeaways
- Revision requests are normal and usually a good sign
- Answer every comment, even the ones you disagree with
- Point to exact locations of each change
- A calm, evidence-based tone persuades editors
Common mistakes
- Ignoring a comment without explanation
- Replying defensively or emotionally
- Changing the paper in ways the letter does not mention
- Missing the revision deadline without telling the editor