Reviewers read many manuscripts. A paper that is clearly organised and matches the journal's requirements makes their job easier and gives your science a fair hearing.
Start with the target journal
Choose the journal before you write the final draft. Its author guidelines set word limits, section order, reference style and figure requirements, and rewriting later costs more time.
- Read the aims and scope and a few recent articles
- Note the word limit, abstract format and reference style
- Check the rules for figures, tables and supplementary files
- Check which ethics, data-availability and authorship statements are required
Structure the paper with IMRaD
Most empirical papers follow Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion.
- Introduction: the problem, the gap and your aim, in that order
- Methods: enough detail for another researcher to repeat the work
- Results: what you found, without interpretation
- Discussion: what it means, how it compares with earlier work, and its limitations
Write the abstract and title last
The abstract is often what reviewers and readers see first. Write it after the paper is finished so it matches what the paper actually says.
- State the aim, method, main result and conclusion
- Keep to the journal's word limit
- Choose keywords people would actually search for
- Make the title informative rather than clever
Final checks before submission
- Every figure and table is cited in the text
- The reference list matches the in-text citations
- Author names, affiliations and ORCIDs agree across all files
- A cover letter explains why the paper fits the journal
- Someone who did not write it has read it for language and formatting
Key takeaways
- Pick the journal first and write to its guidelines
- IMRaD gives reviewers the order they expect
- Write the abstract last so it reflects the finished paper
- A final checklist catches the errors that cause desk rejections
Common mistakes
- Submitting to one journal in another journal's format
- Mixing results and interpretation in the Results section
- Leaving out methods detail that others would need to repeat the work
- Submitting with figures or references that do not match the text